CONTRAST

Composition in numbers

Filter cigarettes VS Heated tobacco products

Per product. Heated tobacco product — THS; filter cigarette — reference 3R4F.

  • Scientific sources and official data
  • One measurement protocol
  • No verdicts, no conclusions
Burning≈ 800 °Cfilter cigarettesSmoke · more harmful constituents
Heating≈ 300 °Cheated tobacco productsAerosol · fewer harmful constituents
SubstanceUnitheated tobacco products300 °Cfilter cigarettes800 °CDifference
General indicators3
Collected Mass (ACM)

Total mass of aerosol or smoke particles collected on a filter pad — a summary measure, not a single substance.

mg47.544.92.6mg5.8 %more at 300 °C, ×1.1
Nicotine (C₁₀H₁₄N₂)

A natural pyridine alkaloid with both psychostimulant and neurotoxic properties. Read more

mg1.071.86+0.79mg+73.8 %more at 800 °C, ×1.7
Glycerol (C₃H₈O₃)

A viscous, colorless, odorless liquid with a sweetish taste — the simplest trihydric alcohol. Read more

mg3.872.261.61mg71.2 %more at 300 °C, ×1.7
Gases5
Carbon monoxide (CO) (CO)

A colorless, odorless gas that reduces the blood’s ability to carry oxygen. Read more

mg0.32430.2+29.876mg+9,220.99 %more at 800 °C, ×93.2
Nitric oxide (NO) (NO)

A colorless gas, a combustion intermediate and a natural signaling molecule in the body. Read more

µg8.95504+495.05µg+5,531.28 %more at 800 °C, ×56.3
Nitrogen oxides (NOx)

A group of gaseous nitrogen oxides formed during combustion that irritate the airways.

µg9.8560+550.2µg+5,614.29 %more at 800 °C, ×57.1
Hydrogen cyanide (HCN)

A volatile liquid or gas smelling of bitter almonds that blocks cellular respiration. Read more

µg2.62365+362.38µg+13,831.3 %more at 800 °C, ×139
Ammonia (NH₃)

A colorless, sharp-smelling gas that irritates the airways and mucous membranes. Read more

µg1029.3+19.3µg+193 %more at 800 °C, ×2.9
Carbonyls8
Formaldehyde (CH₂O)

The simplest aldehyde — a colorless, sharp-smelling gas that irritates mucous membranes; classified as a carcinogen. Read more

µg9.0385.2+76.17µg+843.52 %more at 800 °C, ×9.4
Acetaldehyde (C₂H₄O)

A volatile, sharp-smelling aldehyde and an intermediate product of ethanol metabolism in the body. Read more

µg1581,641+1,483µg+938.61 %more at 800 °C, ×10.4
Acrolein (C₃H₄O)

An unsaturated aldehyde with a pungent odor — a strong irritant of the airways and eyes. Read more

µg7.95156+148.05µg+1,862.26 %more at 800 °C, ×19.6
Butyraldehyde (C₄H₈O)

A sharp-smelling aldehyde used as an intermediate in chemical synthesis. Read more

µg14.183.5+69.4µg+492.2 %more at 800 °C, ×5.9
Acetone (C₃H₆O)

The simplest ketone — a colorless, volatile liquid with a distinctive smell, a common solvent. Read more

µg25.4690+664.6µg+2,616.54 %more at 800 °C, ×27.2
Crotonaldehyde (C₄H₆O)

An unsaturated aldehyde with a sharp odor, a strong irritant of the airways and eyes. Read more

µg1.64550.5+48.855µg+2,969.91 %more at 800 °C, ×30.7
Propionaldehyde (C₃H₆O)

A sharp-smelling aldehyde used as a chemical synthesis intermediate. Read more

µg8.83123+114.17µg+1,292.98 %more at 800 °C, ×13.9
Methyl-ethyl-ketone (MEK) (C₄H₈O)

A volatile ketone smelling like acetone, a common industrial solvent. Read more

µg5.42185+179.58µg+3,313.28 %more at 800 °C, ×34.1
Volatile organic compounds9
1,3-Butadiene (C₄H₆)

A colorless, volatile hydrocarbon used to make synthetic rubber; classified as a human carcinogen. Read more

µg0.1498.5+98.36µg+70,257.14 %more at 800 °C, ×704
Isoprene (C₅H₈)

A volatile hydrocarbon, a natural plant compound and the monomer of natural rubber. Read more

µg1.54894+892.46µg+57,951.95 %more at 800 °C, ×581
Acrylonitrile (C₃H₃N)

A volatile, colorless liquid, the monomer used to make acrylic fibers and plastics. Read more

µg0.053524.5+24.4465µg+45,694.39 %more at 800 °C, ×458
Benzene (C₆H₆)

An aromatic hydrocarbon — a colorless, volatile liquid; classified as a human carcinogen. Read more

µg0.34881.1+80.752µg+23,204.6 %more at 800 °C, ×233
Toluene (C₇H₈)

An aromatic hydrocarbon — a colorless, volatile liquid with a distinctive smell, used as a solvent. Read more

µg1.08137+135.92µg+12,585.19 %more at 800 °C, ×127
Styrene (C₈H₈)

An aromatic hydrocarbon — a colorless liquid, the monomer used to make polystyrene. Read more

µg0.25915.4+15.141µg+5,845.95 %more at 800 °C, ×59.5
Ethylene oxide (C₂H₄O)

A colorless gas used in chemical synthesis and sterilization; classified as a human carcinogen. Read more

µg0.16522.7+22.535µg+13,657.58 %more at 800 °C, ×138
Propylene oxide (C₃H₆O)

A volatile, colorless liquid used as a raw material for polyurethanes; classified as a probable carcinogen. Read more

ng1221,103+981ng+804.1 %more at 800 °C, ×9
Vinyl chloride (C₂H₃Cl)

A colorless gas used as the raw material for PVC; classified as a human carcinogen. Read more

ng0.3285103+102.6715ng+31,254.64 %more at 800 °C, ×314
Tobacco-specific nitrosamines4
N-Nitrosonornicotine (NNN) (C₉H₁₁N₃O)

A tobacco-specific nitrosamine formed during tobacco processing; classified as a human carcinogen. Read more

ng10.6283+272.4ng+2,569.81 %more at 800 °C, ×26.7
4-(Methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone (NNK) (C₁₀H₁₃N₃O₂)

A tobacco-specific nitrosamine derived from nicotine; one of the most potent carcinogens in tobacco smoke.

ng8.95264+255.05ng+2,849.72 %more at 800 °C, ×29.5
N-nitrosoanabasine (NAB) (C₁₀H₁₃N₃O)

A tobacco-specific nitrosamine formed from the alkaloid anabasine during tobacco processing.

ng2.5730.2+27.63ng+1,075.1 %more at 800 °C, ×11.8
N-nitrosoanatabine (NAT) (C₁₀H₁₁N₃O)

A tobacco-specific nitrosamine formed from the alkaloid anatabine during tobacco processing.

ng18.2270+251.8ng+1,383.52 %more at 800 °C, ×14.8
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons4
Benzo[a]pyrene (C₂₀H₁₂)

A polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formed by incomplete combustion; classified as a human carcinogen. Read more

ng0.615+14.4ng+2,400 %more at 800 °C, ×25
Benz[a]anthracene (C₁₈H₁₂)

A polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formed by incomplete combustion; classified as a probable carcinogen. Read more

ng1.2827.1+25.82ng+2,017.19 %more at 800 °C, ×21.2
Dibenz[a,h]anthracene (C₂₂H₁₄)

A polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formed by incomplete combustion; classified as a probable carcinogen. Read more

ng0.0620.853+0.791ng+1,275.81 %more at 800 °C, ×13.8
Pyrene (C₁₆H₁₀)

A polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon formed by the incomplete combustion of organic material. Read more

ng5.2681.8+76.54ng+1,455.13 %more at 800 °C, ×15.6
Aromatic amines5
1-Aminonaphthalene (C₁₀H₉N)

A naphthalene-based aromatic amine used as a chemical synthesis intermediate. Read more

ng0.013521.6+21.5865ng+159,900 %more at 800 °C, ×1,600
2-Aminonaphthalene (C₁₀H₉N)

A naphthalene-based aromatic amine; classified as a human carcinogen. Read more

ng0.00616.2+16.194ng+269,900 %more at 800 °C, ×2,700
3-Aminobiphenyl (C₁₂H₁₁N)

An aromatic amine, an isomer of aminobiphenyl, used as an intermediate in chemical synthesis. Read more

ng0.00414.18+4.1759ng+101,851.22 %more at 800 °C, ×1,020
4-Aminobiphenyl (C₁₂H₁₁N)

An aromatic amine formerly used in industry; classified as a human carcinogen. Read more

ng0.00532.83+2.8247ng+53,296.23 %more at 800 °C, ×534
o-Toluidine (C₇H₉N)

An aromatic amine used as a dye-synthesis intermediate; classified as a human carcinogen. Read more

ng0.887105+104.113ng+11,737.66 %more at 800 °C, ×118
Phenolics7
Phenol (C₆H₆O)

An aromatic compound with a hydroxyl group — a colorless crystalline solid with a distinctive odor. Read more

µg0.98914+13.011µg+1,315.57 %more at 800 °C, ×14.2
Catechol (C₆H₆O₂)

A dihydric phenol — a colorless crystalline solid used as a chemical synthesis intermediate. Read more

µg8.4489.8+81.36µg+963.98 %more at 800 °C, ×10.6
Hydroquinone (C₆H₆O₂)

A dihydric phenol used as a photographic developer and a skin-lightening agent. Read more

µg5.589.1+83.6µg+1,520 %more at 800 °C, ×16.2
Resorcinol (C₆H₆O₂)

A dihydric phenol used in resin manufacturing and as an antiseptic. Read more

µg0.0081.79+1.782µg+22,275 %more at 800 °C, ×224
m-Cresol (C₇H₈O)

A cresol isomer — an aromatic compound with a sharp smell, used as a disinfectant. Read more

µg0.01983.51+3.4902µg+17,627.27 %more at 800 °C, ×177
p-Cresol (C₇H₈O)

A cresol isomer — an aromatic compound with a sharp smell, formed by metabolism and processing. Read more

µg0.04548.63+8.5846µg+18,908.81 %more at 800 °C, ×190
o-Cresol (C₇H₈O)

A cresol isomer — an aromatic compound with a sharp smell, a synthesis intermediate. Read more

µg0.04764.15+4.1024µg+8,618.49 %more at 800 °C, ×87.2
Metals7
Arsenic (As)

A naturally occurring metalloid; inorganic arsenic compounds are classified as human carcinogens. Read more

ng0.3757.9+7.525ng+2,006.67 %more at 800 °C, ×21.1
Cadmium (Cd)

A heavy metal that accumulates in the body; classified as a human carcinogen. Read more

ng0.037592.9+92.8625ng+247,633.33 %more at 800 °C, ×2,477
Chromium (Cr)

A metal; hexavalent chromium compounds are classified as human carcinogens. Read more

ng1.255.5+4.25ng+340 %more at 800 °C, ×4.4
Lead (Pb)

A heavy metal that is toxic to the nervous system and accumulates in the body. Read more

ng0.2532.1+31.85ng+12,740 %more at 800 °C, ×128
Mercury (Hg)

A heavy metal, the only one liquid at room temperature; toxic to the nervous system. Read more

ng1.624.77+3.15ng+194.44 %more at 800 °C, ×2.9
Nickel (Ni)

A metal; certain nickel compounds are classified as human carcinogens. Read more

ng2.57.95+5.45ng+218 %more at 800 °C, ×3.2
Selenium (Se)

A trace element the body needs in tiny amounts, but toxic at higher doses. Read more

ng0.21.95+1.75ng+875 %more at 800 °C, ×9.8
Other substances5
Acetamide (C₂H₅NO)

The simplest amide of acetic acid — a colorless crystalline substance. Read more

µg2.0412.9+10.86µg+532.35 %more at 800 °C, ×6.3
Acrylamide (C₃H₅NO)

A white crystalline solid, the monomer of polyacrylamide; classified as a probable carcinogen. Read more

µg0.7734.46+3.687µg+476.97 %more at 800 °C, ×5.8
Pyridine (C₅H₅N)

A heterocyclic aromatic compound with a sharp odor — a solvent and synthesis intermediate. Read more

µg4.7729.7+24.93µg+522.64 %more at 800 °C, ×6.2
Quinoline (C₉H₇N)

A heterocyclic aromatic compound with a distinctive smell, a synthesis intermediate. Read more

µg0.00550.431+0.4255µg+7,736.36 %more at 800 °C, ×78.4
Nitrobenzene (C₆H₅NO₂)

An aromatic compound smelling of bitter almonds, an intermediate in aniline synthesis. Read more

µg0.00550.019+0.0135µg+245.45 %more at 800 °C, ×3.5

How to read the data

Values are per single product unit and measured under one protocol — Health Canada Intense (HCI). The 300 °C and 800 °C figures describe the process itself, heating and burning, not separate measurement points.

More about the method

Practice

The same substances — in the game

The game module builds molecules from this same table and shows what happens to the composition under heating and burning.

Open the game